Sunday, May 23, 2010

BOOK: The Tale of Hill Top Farm by Susan Wittig Albert

The Tale of Hill Top Farm by Susan Wittig Albert, 286 pages

Historical Mysteries

Cute little cozy mystery set in 1905, in the Lake District of England. Much of the novel is based on the true story of Beatrix Potter, author of the delightful children's books, like The Tale of Peter Rabbit. Albert takes some known facts of Beatrix Potter's life and then builds a whole village around what was known after she left her sheltered parents house. The list of characters at the beginning of the book make clear which characters are based on real people and which are made up. And what a delightful cast of characters populate the village of Near Sawrey!

The mystery is slim in this book, but that is not the appeal. The charm is in the relationships among the characters and the cats and dogs who also live in the town. They have meetings, discuss, and try to solve mysteries as well as the humans. It sounds too cute, but it plays just right. The animals always talked in italics, which helped keep the conversations straight. Miss Potter carries a menagerie of animals with her, so there is also the city mouse meets country mouse aspect to the story. I really liked how the animals played such a part in the plot, unknown to the human characters. The assumption that not much happens in a little village is all a matter of scale - disappearances, deaths, and inheritances take greater relevance when everyone knows everyone else.

Overall, a sweet little mystery. Fans of Beatrix Potter, historical mysteries, English countrysides, and cats would enjoy.


also reviewed:
framed at framed and booked (has the first few books reviewed)
nan at letters from a hill farm (at first I thought her farm was the same name)

Comments (5)

Loading... Logging you in...
  • Logged in as
booklogged's avatar

booklogged · 775 weeks ago

I remember when Framed read and reviewed these books. I wanted to read them then but they fell off the radar, so thanks for refreshing my memory.

You have a new way for us to leave comments. Looks complicated - hope I'm able to figure it out.
booklogged's avatar

booklogged · 775 weeks ago

I did it! Succeeded in leaving a comment, that is. Very easy.
First of all, thank you for mentioning my blog! I was so surprised because I really did love this book and then could not read the others. It seemed like the tone changed. A darkness crept in that I just didn't want in such a book. Darkness in the Scandinavian crime fiction I'm reading is fine because I expect it. :<)
1 reply · active 775 weeks ago
Well that's too bad the tone changed. Although it was awfully sweet, it could use a touch of darkness. I'll try another one and see what happens.
What is it with the Scandinavian's and their crime fiction? Doesn't seem to be any cozy mysteries there. But that's ok, I like my crime dark.

Post a new comment

Comments by