Monday, March 21, 2011

BOOK: An Irish Country Doctor by Patrick Taylor

An Irish Country Doctor by Patrick Taylor, 343 pages

Irish Reading Challenge

It took me a while to get the tone of this book. At first, I thought it would be like the Miss Julia series (Miss Julia Throws a Wedding, Miss Julia Hits the Road), but it wasn't farcical enough. Miss Julia has super broad characters, and often the events become outrageous. That's their charm, since Miss Julia comes off as so prim and proper and she ends up in crazy situations. But Irish Country Doctor isn't like that.

Then I thought the young doctor (Barry) would be more antagonistic to the old doctor (Fingal). That they would be battling the old with the new methods. But no again. Barry is quietly respectful of Fingal, even while disagreeing with him, and Barry is smart enough to realize he has lots to learn. Fingal also sees in Barry a protege, and is smart enough to realize he can learn from the young new doctor. So, Irish Country Doctor isn't like that either.

There are local characters in the book, and it reads more like a LM Montgomery novel set outside Belfast, with the small village, and star crossed lovers, and the lovable main character who finds ways to make it all turn out well in the end. Everyone happy, except the 'bad guy', who gets his comeuppance. So that's what An Irish Country Doctor is like, and  no wonder I enjoyed the book - it reminded me of LM Montgomery and her village stories of interconnected people. And like Montgomery, Taylor keeps writing, so there are more in the series: An Irish Country Village, An Irish Country Christmas, An Irish Country Girl, and An Irish Country Courtship. Lots to look forward to.


also reviewed: beachreader, nan at letters from a hill farm,Nancy Horner (bookfool) reviewed for Estella's Revenge, Lynne at Lynne's Little Corner of the World,

Comments (8)

Loading... Logging you in...
  • Logged in as
I skipped right to the Irish Country Christmas novel, but found it very similar to the relationships in James Herriot's All Creatures Great and Small, which is set in rural England shortly before WWII.
1 reply · active less than 1 minute ago
I'm sure I read Herriot years ago, maybe even in high school? I imagine the tone is similar.

So many bloggers have liked these Irish books, I had to get at it. Pretty perfect reading it over St Patrick's Day.
I love this series! The second one is really good, too. I've also read Irish Country Girl - which is sort of a stand-alone, as it is Kinky's story. I'm waiting for Irish Country Christmas to come on audio from the library. :)
1 reply · active less than 1 minute ago
Kinky's story? that sounds awesome. I'm hoping to read the Village later this year, and be set for the Christmas one at Christmas.

I've made it an Irish March of reading, as am now reading Roddy Doyle's A Star Called Henry. Thanks for hosting!
I really want to read this series! I'm imagining a James Herriot type of vibe, so far I've only read the book about the housekeeper, Kinky, which is supposed to be very different from the rest of the series. It has a supernatural element but I really enjoyed it.
1 reply · active less than 1 minute ago
It's been a long time since I read Herriot. I'm looking forward to the Kinky book. (that sounds so much different than I think it actually is!)
I recently spotted a string of these in the library and was wondering what they'd be like. Your comparison to LMM's stuff definitely piques my interest, but I think much of my love for her work stems to childhood reading memories, so I'm still not sure if I'd warm to this style of storytelling now...
1 reply · active 730 weeks ago
Not written like LM, but the over all feel, - small villages, gentle tone, small secrets. Wait until the mood strikes.
I know what you mean by childhood memories of LM's stories.

Post a new comment

Comments by