Wednesday, August 3, 2011

BOOK: The Box Garden by Carol Shields

The Box Garden by Carol Shields, 213 pages

Canadian Book Challenge 5

I am starting to really enjoy Carol Shields writing. I can't read her books very quickly as her prose is jam packed and it took me a while to read her way. I had already tried a number of her books, (was underwhelmed by The Stone Diaries as my first book but enjoyed The Celibate Season written with Blanche Howard)  but after reading Unless, I decided I wanted to read all her books.   The Box Garden was originally published in 1977 and makes it one of her first novels. My cover is equally as ugly as the one I've shown, but I have been unable to find the actual photo of it. Book covers have taken a decided change in the last few years, and books from the 1980s are so hideous. Someone should compile some ugly book covers from that era. Ew!

But he writes with the most pressing sort of intensity, something much larger than mere eloquence. Anguished. But reflective too. Not like a scientist at all. More like a poet. Or like a philosopher. p81

Charleen Forrest narrates this chapter in her life as she heads home to her mother's wedding in Toronto. It's the late 1970s and Charleen is struggling with her divorce and her seemingly (according to her friends) unsuccessful life on her own. Shields takes the time to develop Charleen and the people around her, but it is mostly about Charleen. The last third of the book takes a surprising turn that throws Charleen's life upside down and made me rush to the end.

I liked the setting and realizing how much life has changed in the last thirty or forty years. I remember being a kid in the late 1970s! When it was a huge deal to make a long distance call. When cross country travel was a big deal. Charleen is coming into her own during a time when many women were learning to live on their own, raise kids, and find themselves. Carol Shields has written a quiet book with a wonderful main character.

Comments (14)

Loading... Logging you in...
  • Logged in as
Going on my list!
1 reply · active less than 1 minute ago
Have you read many Carol Shields? I'm really looking forward to Swann and Happenstance.
Over the years I have read all of Carol Shields books. I hope you continue to enjoy her!
1 reply · active less than 1 minute ago
I'm new to her books, and there are still a lot for me to read. I'm so behind the times.
Do you think twenty, thirty years from now, people will look at the book covers from now and think they are exceptionally ugly? Because I, of course, think they are often of extraordinary beauty, but perhaps I'm just a creature of my times.
2 replies · active 714 weeks ago
I'm sure they will think the covers all ugly - why all the photographs? and no heads on the women? Why so many feet?
You know the clothes you wore in junior high you thought were the bomb, so stylish, and how awful they look in pictures.
I was sure I answered this comment, but it isn't showing up on my blog.

Yes! They will wonder why all the photographs for covers? and why do none of the women have heads? Just like we forget how cool we thought our glasses where in junior high, and how hideous they now look.
I didn't like The Stone Diaries when I read it years ago, but I read Larry's Party earlier this year and loved it. I'm eager to try more of her work, and as you felt similarly about The Stone Diaries, I'll check this one out.
1 reply · active 714 weeks ago
It reminded me more of Unless. I wonder if I go back after reading all her books and try The Stone Diaries if I'll like it then. It has been an acquired reading to get into her books, but now I get it.
I had a tepid reaction to The Stone Diaries but have been meaning to read more of her work. I've just read two of Blanche Howard's books so maybe I'll start with The Celibate Season since I know I like her writing ;)
1 reply · active 713 weeks ago
I saw you had read a Blanche Howard book, and checked my library, but we don't have any other books of hers. There is one book though, of letters between Blanche and Carol that I'm planning to eventually read, once I've read all of Shields other books. I liked The Celibate Season.
I wasn't a fan of The Stone Diaries, but once I read Unless, I was determined to read more Carol Shields.
Even if you're not usually a fan of short stories, given how much you are enjoying even her early novels, I bet you'd find yourself quite pleased with them as well. I have a long list of quotes from this one, but it's been ages since I re-read it. You've tempted me though!
1 reply · active 713 weeks ago
I actually am a fan of short stories. I've read one of her collections so far, earlier this year. I am enjoying her books, a lot.
I just finished this one last week! I really do love Carol Shields so much.

Post a new comment

Comments by