Wednesday, September 5, 2012

BOOK: Broken Harbour by Tana French

Broken Harbour by Tana French, 533 pages

Ireland Reading Challenge; Series Goals (Dublin Murder Squad #4)

 It's a mystery series, but a most unusual series. The main character changes with each book. Sometimes previous main characters appear, but sometimes they don't. The only pattern I can see is that each main character made an appearance in the previous book. I guessed wrong from the last book, as this book has Mick 'Scorcher' Kennedy for our lead detective. I wasn't really impressed with him in the last book, but  he made a good main character and as more of his background was revealed, his character becomes more understandable.

The horrific murder here is a family that has been butchered, two children and the parents, with the wife hanging on in the hospital. Mick is juggling his own family issues, a mentally upset sister, along with training a new partner. The murder actually occurred where Mick and his family spent summer vacations, and there is some tragedy associated with Broken Harbour.

French writes about modern Ireland, including life after the economic bust after the boom. She can be a tad long-winded, but I am noticing this less with each successive book, and am enjoying her writing more with each book. Broken Harbour was a fabulous read, a touch Gothic, twists and turns, with wonderfully layered characters. As in the first book, In the Woods, there were a few threads left unexplained, but nothing is ever as it seems, and not everything can be tied up neatly. I appreciate this about French's writing. I can't wait for the next book by French.

Comments (15)

Loading... Logging you in...
  • Logged in as
There is something so good about Tana French's writing isn't there. I just finished Faithful Place last week and thoroughly enjoyed it
1 reply · active 655 weeks ago
I find her writing getting better and better with each book. Faithful Place was a really good read as well.
This is an author I want to read so badly. I hope to start this series next year.
1 reply · active 655 weeks ago
It's such a unique series with different characters. The books are barely connected!
I really enjoyed Faithful Place as well, though it was tricky with how the story kept unwinding to what happened. I haven't picked up Broken Harbour yet, though I have held it in my hands. Love this review, and definitely want to get to it this fall now.
1 reply · active 655 weeks ago
It kept twisting around and around. So did this one! I liked seeing how they figured out what they did.
Ps I meant to say, that the ending to her first book really bothered me - I didn't like that hardly anything was wrapped up in that one! It felt almost like a cheat. So I will keep it in mind that this one might have a loose end or two as well. And see how I like it here,because she does write well.
1 reply · active 655 weeks ago
Nothing as loose as In the Woods. I really thought it would get dealt with in the next book, but nooo. I think each book is getting tighter though, and better.
Planning to read this one soon - as soon as my name comes up on the library list!
1 reply · active 655 weeks ago
I'm on a very long list for Gone Girl, so I feel for you.
I have this one on hold at the library. Been waiting for a while as there are many folks in front of me! I agree that Tana French's writing is getting better with each novel. Thanks for this review!
1 reply · active 655 weeks ago
thanks for stopping by Gavin. Some books take so long to actually get at the library, you almost forget why you requested it in the first place. Still, awesome system for getting great books free.
I NEED to get back to reading this author! I read In The Woods a few years back and have meant to read the 2nd one since then. Thanks for the kick in the butt to do just that :)
1 reply · active 654 weeks ago
I've got a ton of other authors like that, but this year I read a lot of French and Meyer.
booklogged's avatar

booklogged · 650 weeks ago

I should have listened to the voice in my head that told me not to read any more reviews tonight. This is another series I need to get caught up with. Didn't even know there was a 4th.

Post a new comment

Comments by