Monday, November 22, 2010

BOOK: What is Stephen Harper Reading? by Yann Martel

What is Stephen Harper Reading? by Yann Martel, 228 pages

Bibliophilic Challenge; 4th CBC Challenge;

Just as a hockey game can't be reduced to its score, so a work of art can't be reduced to a summary. p174

Yann Martel started sending Prime Minister Stephen Harper a book, every two weeks, when Harper first came to power in April 2007. (Oh, dear, has he been PM that long? Sigh.)  Accompanying each book is a letter from Martel. Martel is hopeful to get a response sometime (other than the 2 replies from Harper's assistants.) This book is composed of the first two years of their 'book club', but it has been continuing, since Harper is still in power, albeit a minority government that never seems to collapse. (The letters are actually posted on a website, so it is possible to read the letters without the book, but the book allowed me to read on the couch.) It would be nice to think that Harper has read a few of the books Martel sent. I do believe in some ways Martel is rather optimistic, because he isn't picking some of the easiest books to read, but he explains his rationale for each book in the letter.He does try to make them all relatively short, since he acknowledges that Harper is a busy guy.

Notice how I subtly show my bias towards our Canadian leader; Martel is just as subtle in many of his letters. It is interesting to watch the progression of his letters, as Martel begins to lament some decisions, generally cuts to the Arts, of the Harper government. Martel also includes some history of books, rationale behind the importance of reading a variety of books, and some critiques of books as well. I particularly like how he sent him one of Michael Ignatieff's books. Ignatieff is the Leader of the Opposition who spent many years abroad, teaching and writing. He even has a Booker shortlisted book. Wouldn't Harper want to read a book by Ignatieff to get an insight into his opponent?

I've read eleven of the books sent, including Maus, Animal Farm, Mister Pip, The Cellist of Sarajevo and Gilead, sent because Obama had mentioned reading and enjoying the book. There are some I've wanted to read, like The Good Earth, and a few I'd like to read after this book's recommendation, The Gift and Oranges are Not the Only Fruit.There is even a group at Librarything trying to read all the books sent to Harper by Martel.

Comments (6)

Loading... Logging you in...
  • Logged in as
I've enjoyed the letters that I've read on the site; it would be great fun to try to read all the books. I wonder if anyone on the PM's staff is required to read them (note how I subtly reveal my complete and utter disbelief that SH has read even a single one of the bunch).
1 reply · active less than 1 minute ago
I like how most recently he's had some guest writers send in books and letters as well. I doubt he's read any of them. If The Guiness Book of Records is one of his favorite books or most recently read, then he's not reading novels.
I have been so very fascinated by this since I found out about the site. I'll guess I heard about it from John at The Book Mine Set. What an intriguing, important thing. I'm quite sure nothing like this has ever been done before. I haven't visited the website in a while. How could the PM NOT read any of them when such an effort was made? I didn't know there was a book. You know, down here :<) I think of Canada as being very supportive of the arts. Speaking of Prime Ministers, I just saw THE BEST dvd about Pierre Elliot Trudeau. It was called 'Memoirs' I think. We just saw the first dvd, and have since given up Netflix so not sure if I'll be able to see the others. Even as a kid, I was sorta wowed by him, and now even more so.
1 reply · active less than 1 minute ago
Well, relatively speaking, I guess Canada is supportive of the arts, but Harper admires the Republican model of politics, so things have been cut. Martel makes the point for the arts continuously in his letters.

Ah, PET. He was very wow. He and Kennedy both came out of the 60s and had that it factor. Trudeau was such an intellect. His son is now an MP in parliament and is very charming as well. 'Just watch me!'
I have mixed feelings about this. Part of me thinks it's a neat idea, and part of me feels like it is just so, so condescending. I'm all for reading like a fiend, but you can't make people do it. They do it if they want to and have time, and they don't if they don't.
1 reply · active 748 weeks ago
Oh, it's very condescending. But Harper is extremely dismissive of the arts, and Martel is trying to show him how important artistic things are. The book Harper said he last read/enjoyed was The Guiness Book of Records. I'd like to think my PM has read something. It's a lot of the fact that there's hope that reading might expand his view of other people. It's easier to be annoyed at him when you disagree with his politics.

Post a new comment

Comments by