Monday, March 19, 2012

BOOK: Faithful Place by Tana French

Faithful Place by Tana French, 438 pages

Ireland Reading Challenge; Series Goals (Dublin Murder Squad, book 3)

The Plot:
Frank Mackey, undercover operative last seen as Cassie Maddox's boss in The Likeness, is the main character in the third Dublin Murder Squad book. Twenty odd years ago, he was set to elope with the girl next door, Rosie Daly, to London, but she never turned up. He left Faithful Place (his neighbourhood street) and his family, and started a new life. Suddenly, her suitcase turns up in an abandoned building in the old neighbourhood. Frank is pulled back to the family and forced to examine all that he thought was true, ie, Rosie dumped him and left without him. Now, it appears she had been killed or at least never made it to London. Can you ever escape your family and where you come from?

The Good: 
  • I like how this series is only partly a series. Each book, so far, takes one of the characters and sends them off to their own book. 
  • This one had less intrigue to the mystery, but it reminded me of a Cold Case episode. I always liked that show, and at the end of the book, I could see it being filmed in my head. Overlapping the present confession, with the 'event' from the past, with all the emotions that had been held in for twenty years, just bubbling to the surface.
  • I liked Frank with his Irish family, stereotypical as they were. The harpy, mean mother, the angry alcoholic father, the wild children. However, it is stereotypical for a reason, and stereotypes are built on real situations.
  • I liked the culprit, and felt so sorry for [him/her]. My heart broke actually. It was just like the Cold Case shows, in that final scene, when the music plays, and the case is solved, that is always so sad.
  • I think I know who will be the lead in the next book, Broken Harbour, due to be published June 5, 2012. A character, Stephen, was introduced that is just screaming to get his own book
  • The writing. French has a tendency to ramble on a bit, and her books could be a bit shorter, but I enjoy my time reading them, and I like her turn of phrase. Upon the discovery of Rosie Daly's suitcase, "Ma said, with a nice blend of awe, envy and blood lust, 'Therese Daly'll go mental. Mental." p26
The Bad:
  • Frank is a tough character to like, but the reasons for his behaviour are all very clear, once you meet his family and see his upbringing. Doesn't mean I liked him, but I get him.
  • There was no Cassie Maddox or Robert Ryan and I was hoping they would make an appearance at some point.
Clearly the good outweigh the bad, which were nit picky at best. This is a great series and I'm looking forward to the next book.

Getting caught up on my series' goals has been great.  I've got six that are up to date! Sadly, for me, they are all having new books come out this year! Plus, I found a couple more new series to read - Mrs Pollifax and Inspector Brunetti are both excellent with a huge backlist.

    Comments (5)

    Loading... Logging you in...
    • Logged in as
    I'm thinking of trying again with Tana French. I liked In the Woods (was that what it was called?) well enough, didn't love it, but everyone loves Tana French so much! I should give her another try when everyone loves her so much.
    1 reply · active 680 weeks ago
    I liked The Likeness the best, although Cassie was a bit pigheaded. This one was good as well, but less mystery.
    Not everyone likes everything - don't be peer pressured into reading something you don't love.
    I really enjoyed this one, too - and absolutely can't wait for Broken Harbour! I added this review to the main challenge page. :)
    1 reply · active 680 weeks ago
    Broken Harbour looks good. I finally found a summary, and I picked the wrong detective, but I'll bet Stephen is a part of it, and he can have the next book.
    Susan said:
    I enjoyed this book when I read it last year, too. I like how we get the story slowly being unravelled so that the past meets the present at the end, and the terrible truth is revealed. It was a little shocking even though I could guess some of it. The family are really not pleasant, and yet - it seems real, doesn't it? This is an interesting series, she is certainly writing very different and good mysteries.

    Post a new comment

    Comments by