Sunday, June 10, 2012

BOOK: When She Woke by Hillary Jordan

When She Woke by Hillary Jordan, 340 pages

When She Woke is Hillary Jordan's fantastic retelling of The Scarlet Letter by Nathanial Hawthorne, but a futuristic version. Instead of Hester Prynne being forced to wear the red letter A on her clothes, for adultery, after having a baby with minister Arthur Dimmesdale in Puritan America, we have Hannah Payne who is 'chromed' red after having an abortion with evangelical minister Aiden Dale in a future America. Both women refuse to name the father of their child, and in both cases, only the woman is punished.

Sidetrack: I read The Scarlet Letter when it was about to be remade into a movie starring Demi Moore in 1995. I accidentally picked up The Scarlet Pimpernell which turned out to be a far superior book in my view. When I finally read The Scarlet Letter, I was terribly bored. It was the style of writing, late 19th century American writing more than the story which bothered me. The plot and characters were fine, but I cannot stand that prose. I was put off enough by the book that I never did see the movie, but I am glad that I read the book, if only to have the literary references to read When She Woke. Ah, classic novels. We have to read you if only to better appreciate the homages that are written. I loved Bridget Jones' Diary, but after reading Pride and Prejudice, I appreciated it even more.

Back to When She Woke, which is really the beautiful child of The Scarlet Letter and The Handmaid's Tale. I could predict the arc of the story: Young naive girl has never questioned the world she lives in. Suddenly thrust into reality of her world, she meets brave people who rebel against all she has believed, and gradually, through some dangerous situations, faces the truth of the society that has kept her down, and recognizes the wrong in her past beliefs. As predictable as all dystopian novels, Jordan does an excellent job of following the standard steps, and making characters that are believable, and still adding some plot twists to keep the reader entertained. As I carried this book around in the past week, I pushed and or recommended this book to all my reading friends.

There is a religious aspect to the novel, as Hannah is forced to examine her beliefs, and her God. Jordan exposes Hannah to several extremes, and while the author's view comes through (I think) she does present different sides, (kind of like Stephen Colbert does!) This book was only released in October 2011, so it is still a fairly new release.  I saw it was picked as a possible Orange nominee on a couple of predicting lists, which is what piqued my interest. Fans of Jordan's first novel, Mudbound, will be especially impressed with the author's versatility and talent.

also reviewed: sophia at page plucker; lavender lines; leeswammer's blog; rhapsody in books; softdrink at fizzy thoughts; kailana at the written world; bookfool at bookfoolery;

Comments (4)

Loading... Logging you in...
  • Logged in as
I'm glad you enjoyed this too. I thought it wobbled a bit at the end, but overall it was really well done. It'll be interesting to see what Hillary Jordan comes up with next.
1 reply · active 668 weeks ago
Yes, she's such a versatile writer. Two excellent, yet different books.
>>Sidetrack: I read The Scarlet Letter when it was about to be remade into a movie starring Demi Moore in 1995. I accidentally picked up The Scarlet Pimpernell which turned out to be a far superior book in my view.

Okay, this is my favorite Scarlet Letter anecdote ever AND an amazing idea. If I ever have a kid who has to read The Scarlet Letter in school, I'm going to give him/her The Scarlet Pimpernel instead and be like, "Oo, my bad, they both start with Scarlet, I just got mixed up," and then my kid, like you, can steer clear of the rotten Scarlet Letter.
1 reply · active 668 weeks ago
yep, rotten Scarlet Letter. It's like a lot of classics though - the story sounds okay, but the execution is mind-numbing. That's why I like the movies of a lot of classics, or modern retellings.

And the best part of The Scarlet Pimpernel, is watching the Wayne and Shuster skit - The Brown Pumpernickel. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wfIimbg2oSw
Have you ever seen Wayne and Shuster show, an old CBC skit show from the 70s. But they are the comedy team that appeared most on the old Ed Sullivan show. (I'm such a fountain of useless info!) Their best skit is probably Julius Caesar. Some rainy day, you should check out their skits on youtube.

Post a new comment

Comments by