Tuesday, March 13, 2018

UPDATE: February Reads, vol 1

I read 12 books in February. After my great last year of reading nonfiction, I only managed one this month, and it was a re-read for my book club. Half my reads were audiobooks, probably because a number of the paper books felt like they took forever to finish. Today I'll review some of the slower and problematic reads of the month. Some other categories I hope to get to include my favourite reads of the month, some continuing series books, and a few featured on the Tournament of Books at themorningnews.


The Devil of Nanking by Mo Hayder, 363 pages

I read and loved Hayder's Jack Caffrey series. Jack was a great if troubled police detective, and the books veered into super creepy. I tried this stand-alone that revolves around the Nanking Massacre from the 1930s. Two stories occurred in two time periods and I could never decide which if either, story I was liking more. If I thought the Caffrey series was creepy, Hayder ventures into new taboo areas. I continued reading even while it was a very slow set up because I have liked Hayder's writing. I'll give Hayder another chance.




Wide Sargasso Sea by Jean Rhys, 150 pages

How such a short book could take so long to read was very disappointing. I liked the Jane Eyre book, I really liked the movie, and I also enjoy reading women writing about their love of Jane Eyre. I missed this whole oeuvre in my younger days and I wanted to read this prequel of sorts, the story of how Rochester's first wife ended up the crazy woman in the attic.
Mostly set in the Caribbean, it was slow, the writing didn't flow for me, and the characters did not evoke any attachments for me. I didn't get a good sense of what the point of the book was, even though I did know. It picked up a bit when Mr Rochester arrived, but not enough to explain to me how she ended up in the attic.

Planet of Exile by Ursula Le Guin (4 h 30 min)

After the death of LeGuin, I looked for an audiobook that was available and fairly short. I'm not a huge fan of science fiction, but I have read some famous ones that I have enjoyed. Two tribes of people have lived for generations on a planet. They stick to their traditional ways, but of course, some one is trying to change things. There's a battle. I know now that general sci-fi is not for me. Sorry fans of Ursula K LeGuin.

The Absolutely True Diary of a Part-Time Indian by Sherman Alexie, 288 pages

I finally read this multi-award winning book for young adults. Then in the next month, Alexie gets called out for very bad behaviour. I also read and enjoyed Al Franken last year. Stop ruining good reading experiences by being assholes, guys.
This was an easy read, but frustrating at the same time as the narrator deals with racism and trying to take control of his life. Being a teenager isn't easy, and one living on a reservation has extra problems. Alexie writes a thoughtful and engaging book with a great narrator.

Comments (7)

Loading... Logging you in...
  • Logged in as
Wide Sargasso Sea is one of those books I read during grad school that I mean to revisit at some point. Isn't it one of those stories, like The Yellow Wallpaper, meant to suggest that the impinging of a woman's free spirit is akin to being physically trapped and that the disallowed desire to have unrestrained free will is tantamount to going mad?

Also, I agree with you about Alexie, his book, and sucky guys (and people) in general.
1 reply · active 367 weeks ago
That is a good analysis and makes clear that I was not a Lit major, lol. Got any graphs needing analysis? I did recognize that there must have been more to the book, and it would have been better to be reading it in a lit class with the chance to discover the meanings.
I love Mo Hayder's books, but haven't read all of them and it's been a long time since I read one. She certainly does do creepy! Not sure about this stand-alone, though. You have inspired me, though, to pick up Pig Island, which is on my bookcase (where it's been for a few years!).

I really liked the Alexie book, but am so sad that he is one of those men who just doesn't know his boundaries with women. I just don't understand these guys!
1 reply · active 367 weeks ago
I'll still try Pig Island by Hayder.

The Alexie book was a great read. I'm getting a kick/infuriated out of the news articles about male managers concerned about being alone with women and how their careers could be in danger. Gee, maybe women have always had to deal with this same issue? It's about time men had to think about that as well. Grr.
Is that the only Le Guin book you've tried? Maybe you would get on with her fiction better? Searoad is lovely. Her essays maybe? But, then, I'm a fan. Of her worldview as much as of her writing. Although I'm not sure that any of the sci-fi books which are part of the overarching cycle are necessarily as satisfying when viewed outside the cycle as individual books.
2 replies · active 367 weeks ago
Aw, I knew I would upset a Le Guin fan. I understand that there are books and authors where the individual books are less than the series or writings as a whole. But sci-fi really isn't my favourite genre. And there are soo many authors and books to read, having one less to worry about it okay for me.
Heheh I know there isn't always a match to be made, but there are things about LeGuin's worldview that do seem to suit you, based on some of the other books and authors I know you enjoy, which is why I wonder if her straight fiction (literary fiction, not science-fiction) might still be a fit, stepping away from the genre that you're not keen on. A lot of people think of her as only writing sci-fi but she was a suprisingly versatile writer! But I don't have a title to recommend to you either, because my favourite of that lot is Searoad, which is short stories, and I don't think you're especially fond of those...

Post a new comment

Comments by